Thursday, April 27, 2017

resistance vs oppression. Stephen Duncombe and CLR James

In the chapter by C. L. R. James, he talks about a situation where an individual has to choose between to states of being. He refers to them as “the rebel’ or “a Puritan.” In the reading, it discusses a lot about the imposing of cultural oppression or imperialism. When more thought is placed on this concept, there really is only the two responses of obedience and rebellion. This is weighed out by cost and effect. The subject of the reading experienced a great deal of oppression, however there were also consequences if he were to ack out against them. This is another form of oppression. While there may be a major negative effect from the oppressive system, there has to be a choice to determine if opposing that system is will produce better results. In the second reading, it discusses the need to oppose the British rule through different ways. The most interesting line is, “we shall gradually do away with it.” Although this line refers to machinery, it can be applied to both readings. The cost of opposition can depend on the degree in which something is imposed. For those who cannot openly rebel, there are subtle ways to oppose cultural oppression such as boycotts and refusal of minor rules. This represents the idea of everyday resistance. The resistance of opposition may not happen in a short period of time, but with little actions it will happen eventually. 

No comments:

Post a Comment